|
|
|
| | |
| | |
"In a timely and compelling documentary, PBS' FRONTLINE examines "The
Princess and the Press." An absorbing examination of public images and the
private machinations to maintain those facades, the film takes a hard look at
how the press came to rule Britain's royal family--with Diana becoming the
jewel in that crown."
"...Even though you might have heard all of this before, the FRONTLINE
examination is powerful. So much because the documentary amasses all the
information--complete with interviews from many Fleet Street principals--and
builds a strong, dramatic story of this unfortunate woman and her dangerous
tactics in the fame game."
"...'The Princess and the Press' will satisfy the Diana craving. On the basest
level, the documentary exploits the princess yet again. But there's much to
ponder here--for journalists, and for those who criticize the swarm media
mentality."
|
| |
|
|
|
"Normally, PBS's FRONTLINE is a welcome antidote to these distressing
trends, rolling out thoughtful in-depth documentaries that frame issues in the
necessary context. But that's hardly the case with "The Princess and the
Press."
"...Covering ground that was thoroughly tilled during the Great Diana Media
Wallow of September, "P&P's" thesis is that the Princess of Wales grew from
being a naive victim of the tabloids into a savvier woman who was a victim part
of the time, but also a manipulator. The evidence for this was aired ad
infinitum previously. .
Sorry, but it didn't wash then, and even strung out to 90 minutes now, it
hasn't gained any credibility. While there may be a shred of truth to the
argument, there's a much stronger stench of an embarrassed British press, both
tabloid and mainstream, protesting that it really wasn't their fault.
FRONTLINE usually plays several levels about this shallow level of
muddy thinking and regurgitated analysis.
|
| |
|
|
|
"The pitiless conclusion of FRONTLINE 's 'The Princess and the Press'
is that Diana 'played a dangerous game, and she lost.' True enough, though the
heart still cracks to see how the demurely downcast eyes of 19-year-old Diana
Spencer became the beseeching eyes of a media quarry.
But eerily fascinating thing about this documentary is that it suggests there
was a fatefulness, almost an inevitability, to Diana's tragedy."
"Whatever Diana's degree of complicity in the media dance, viewers will likely
get a queasy feeling at the sight of a vulnerable woman being stalked by packs
of photographers, almost all of them men. (And isn't it odd how little the
male-female power dynamic has been remarked upon in all the Diana stories?)
Fittingly, and no doubt deliberately, one of the final images of 'The Princess
and the Press' is of Diana's casket being transported through darkened streets,
illuminated by the glare of countless flashbulbs."
|
| |
|
|
|
"In need of another Diana fix? Tonight's supplier is not your common news
magazine, but the usually upright FRONTLINE . The pretext for 'The
Princess and the Press' is an investigation of the relationship between the
Princess of Wales and Britain's tabloids. If that sounds a little familiar,
well, after the Anglo-American gush set off by Diana's death, what about her
isn't familiar?"
"...It is easier to understand why the British press and much of American
television should go gaga over the Diana saga than why FRONTLINE should
belatedly contribute. For all the reporting, the program is not particularly
revealing with its by-now-familiar Diana pictures and gossip that have already
clogged up so many hours of tube time. 'The Princess and the Press'...is a
paltry sort of journalism. The Princess has seduced FRONTLINE. Can the
nanny be far behind?
|
| |
|
|
|
"'The Princess and the Press'...is a testament to the ultimate in mutually
destructive relationships, we are not talking about the one between Diana and
Charles (or the Queen), but between Diana and the Fleet Street. At her death,
Diana was the most famous woman in the world, yet such renown in the
media-drunk late 20th Century has--shall we say--its own peculiar drawbacks.
Meanwhile, one simply shudders to imagine the dramatic circulation declines
threatening England's tabloids now that their favorite subject is dead and
buried..
Anyone who is not moved by Diana's plight during tonight's program is a
stone-hearted miscreant. But beware. If it's villains you want, 'The Princess
and the Press' will disappoint, because this intelligent and thoughtful program
gives a body blow to the theory many people have taken for granted, namely that
Di was killed by the press. Instead, FRONTLINE drops a step back to
ask this crucial question: What, exactly, was Diana's role in this
'doomed embrace' . The answer will provide cold comfort to her bereaved
fans.
|
| |
|
|
|
"FRONTLINE in an attempt to deliver good journalism about a tawdry
subculture of journalism, takes the long view, tracking the evolving nature of
the royal family's often muddy relationship with the papers and photographers.
No one emerges shining from this gossipy game of give and take."
"...There are few surprises in this investigation of which side used the press
when, but it is helpful to be reminded in no uncertain terms that there are
limitations to public-relations spin. Where 'The Princess and the Press' is
most lacking is in any analysis of why Diana's story registered so deeply with
us, even before its unhappily-ever-after conclusion.
|
| |
|
|
|
"'The Princess and the Press' is after more than just royal dirt, Diana
glorification or paparazzi bashing. Rather, it explains the media fascination
with her and the complicated, sometimes mutually beneficial dance between
Diana and the press.
As such, the report reflects well on no one, no Diana, Prince Charles, the
media or the public that lapped up every detail. This may not be what Diana
groupies want, but it's a perspective that this widely reported story
needed."
|
| |
|
|
|
"The 90-minute report also reminds us that Diana's love/hate relationship with
the press led her to frequently use and exploit its power to influence minds.
It stops short of calling her a tease who finally worked the pack up to a
lather she couldn't control, but it certainly doesn't find her blameless.
Oddly, the program, called 'The Princess and the Press,' really doesn't spend
any time investigating the role of the tabloid photographers in the Paris car
crash that took Diana's life, so those expecting the usual FRONTLINE
revelations will be disappointed."
"...Yet FRONTLINE reminds us that long after the marriage was over,
Diana commonly used 'exclusive' interviews with tabloid papers to settle scores
with Charles and the queen and frequently solicited press coverage to promote
her many causes. Her scandalous biography by Andrew Morton, with whom she
cooperated, was even serialized in a Murdoch tabloid.
Was that enough to suggest Diana deserved what she ultimately got--a life as
the prey of the media? I don't think so, but the FRONTLINE
report comes close to embracing that outlook."
|
| |
|
| |
home .
join the discussion .
pictures .
bbc interview .
interviews .
readings
morton book controversy .
press & the royal family .
links .
press reaction .
tapes & transcripts
web site copyright WGBH educational foundation
|
|