Paul Goldberger is the architecture critic for The New Yorker and the author of Up from Zero: Politics, Architecture, and the Rebuilding of New York. He recounts how and why politics and design clashed in the building of the Freedom Tower at Ground Zero and describes the end result as "a well-meaning but sad compromise." He tells FRONTLINE: "I think it was a mistake to believe that two good architects, because they're both good architects with intelligent ideas and a commitment to Ground Zero, therefore can produce a single work that will be a coherent and good work. We had what I think is actually an unsuccessful collaboration, because the end result is not as good as either of their buildings were when they had their own separate ideas and visions for them."
|