|
It's as though we'd become intent on running history backward around here, at
hyperspeed," the independent Bosnian Serb journalist Perica Vucinic said to me
one recent afternoon as we shared a few cups of the sort of mud-thick black
coffee that the locals used to call Turkish, though not anymore. We'd been
talking about life in the Republika Srpska, the ethnically cleansed Serb
component, or "entity," of the Republic of Bosnia-Herzegovina. The Bosnian
Serbs had splintered off from the wider Bosnian Republic at the very moment it
had declared its own independence, in the spring of 1992, provoking a horrible
three-and-a-half year war. That war culminated in a peace conference in
Dayton, Ohio, in the late 1995, from which emerged a tortuous agreement that
yoked the Serb entity, the Republika Srpska, ever so tenuously to its
counterpart, the Muslim-Croat Federation.
Vucinic laughed bitterly and went on, "In less than a decade; we've managed to
go from a seedy variation of twentieth-century post-Communism through an
exceptionally florid version of nineteenth-century romantic nationalism into a
full-fledged rendition of deep medieval feudalism. Look at us. We've become a
land consisting of a few spectacularly rich warlords and their legions of
pampered vassals, with everyone else reduced to something between indentured
servitude and wretched peonage."
Drawing on their beloved medieval epics, the Serbs of Bosnia had just about
managed to forge for themselves an ethnically pure medieval fate. Terrorized
by visions of being enslaved to rampaging Turks (as their leaders had taken to
characterizing their longtime Muslim neighbors), they had instead become
subjugated to those very leaders who had inflamed and then purported to defend
them.
Vucinic's comment haunted me throughout my recent stay in the Republika Srpska,
especially late one afternoon as I was returning from a visit to the cemetery
on the outskirts of Bijeljina, a medium-sized country town in the northeastern
corner of the Serbian entity. The cemetery itself had been an overwhelming
experience, its acre upon acre of fresh graves reminding one that hundreds of
thousands of Serbs had also suffered in the recent Bosnian fighting.
It's worth recalling, too, that the war's outset the Bosnian Serbs had had a
constitutional case just as strong as that of their Muslim and Croat neighbors,
in fact, the two cases were virtually identical. Once the former Yugoslavia
began breaking up, in the early nineties (setting aside, for a moment, the
question of who bore principal responsibility for that disastrous sequence of
developments), the Muslims and the Croats and the cosmopolitan nonnationalists
of Bosnia had had every right to declare that they didn't care to participate
in the remaining Yugoslav state, suddenly dominated by a Serb majority at least
momentarily in the grip of a truly scary hypernationalist rapture. So they had
opted for independence.
But, by the same logic, the Serb third of that new Bosnian state had had every
right to assert their own misgivings--and they'd have been in a position to
bring a powerful moral weight to those arguments, having been principal victims
of German and Croatian Fascism fifty years earlier. At the time, they had
responded heroically, emerging from that war with the aura of one of the
century's more valiant peoples. Drawing on that legacy, today's Bosnian Serb
leaders could have marshaled a singularly compelling non-violent struggle on
behalf of maximal national autonomy. But, because of the appalling viciousness
of the war upon which they instead chose to embark, those same leaders recast
themselves and the people they represented as among history's moral pariahs--a
remarkable achievement.
And in the process they squandered the lives of thousands of their own people,
as I was reminded that afternoon in the Bijeljina cemetery, with its row upon
row of gray ranite tombstones. Photo-realist likenesses of the deceased
(casually posed, often in military fatigues) had been etched into the polished
stone. Born 1975, dead 1992. Born 1971, born 1965, born 1952, born 1940, born
1980. Two teen-age brothers born within a year of each other, slain within a
month. Eight male members of one family killed on the same day. A
two-year-old girl. Another child, born 1991. And another. And another. A
whole swath of the cemetery had been given over to the relatives of the
refugees routed from western Herzegovina and the Croatian Krajina during the
closing days of the war. These particular graves were marked by rickety wooden
crosses, and there were scores of them.
The area around Bijeljina is flat and bountifully fertile. But, driving back
toward town, one couldn't help noticing how many of the fields now lay idle,
overgrown with weeds. Almost all the original farmers--prosperous Muslims,
many of whom lived in town and headed out to their fields early each
morning--had been systematically removed during the war, murdered, terrorized,
or evicted en masse (many ending up, now landless, of course, and bereft of
occupation, wedged, with their families, into squalid one-or two- room
apartments in Tuzla, about thirty miles to the south, in the Muslim--Croat
Federation). They'd been replaced, for the most part, by Serbs from the
scrabbly, rocky hill country to the south and west--accomplished shepherds and
goatherds, who had also been victims of cleansings, and who hadn't the faintest
idea how to plant crops or manage fields. Somehow, the nationalist ideologues
who had blithely advocated the redrawing of borders and the shuffling of entire
populations had failed to anticipate the difficulty of transferring the entire
fabric of lives and livelihoods. The new arrivals either milled about in
public squares, abject and shiftless and bored out of their minds, or scraped
by on what they could earn hawking cheap goods at the ubiquitous flea
markets.
Not that the town's economy had become entirely cratered. For one thing, those
who had actually engineered the cleansing had made handsome fortunes in the
process--initially by confiscating virtually all the possessions of those they
were evicting but then by turning such new-honed skills on their remaining
countrymen. One of the principal figures involved in the cleansing of
Bijeljina, for instance, had become a specialist in security services and real
estate, shaking down local businessmen and offering incoming Serb refugees
their pick of "abandoned" homes, provided that they could come up with the
requisite sweetener.
Bejeljina's geographical location--wedged right up against the border with
Serbia proper--had also made it an ideal center for smuggling and contraband
activities, especially after punitive embargoes started getting imposed on the
Republika Srpska as the war dragged on. The same leaders who managed the
town's cleansing and in the years since had taken up positions of authority in
its civilian, police, and customs establishments--"the mob," or "the mafia," as
everyone else started referring to them in hushed tones--took charge of this
fleecing as well, skimming tidy cuts off the top of every shipment of gasoline,
cigarettes, alcohol, or anything else attempting to come in over the border.
It's no wonder that on the way back into town from the cemetery one could spot,
scattered among desolate and dilapidated housing blocks, several improbably
opulent dachas and villas, in various states of completion, and often already
expansively outfitted with the toniest of furnishings and accouterments (many
of them procured through the thriving Gianni Versace boutique in Belgrade).
The town's factories were virtually idle. They'd been replaced by ludicrously
extravagant gasoline stations--petrol palaces, 7-Elevens on steroids, framed by
kitsch-slender Corinthian columns--and by a veritable cornucopia of brothels.
A town of about fifty thousand, Bijeljina now had eight such emporiums. ("Dodge
City," as a friend of mine muters.) The second most luxurious of them sued to
be owned by the former chief of police (who recently cashed out); the most
luxurious is said to be controlled, through relatives, by the head of the local
branch of the ruling S.D.S. Party.
Meanwhile, my friend's father, a long-time schoolteacher, hasn't received a
paycheck in more than six months: the town's coffers are desperately depleted,
he has been begged to understand.
Much the same situation exists throughout the rest of the Republika Srpska.
Prijedor, in the northwest corner, was the site of some of the most vicious
fighting at the outset of the war, in which fifty-five thousand local Muslims
and Croats were ethnically cleansed, many by way of the notorious concentration
camps at Omarska, Keraterm, Tmopolje, and Manjaca: stripped of their
possessions, the victims were forced at knifepoint to sign over deeds to any
real property before being expelled--those who survived, anyway--into desperate
exile. The police chief who played a leading role in that bloody operation,
Simo Drljaca, managed to retain control over the resulting purified
opstina , or district. Locally, he was known as Mr. Ten Per Cent,
because of the kickbacks and extortion payments he squeezed from almost every
commercial enterprise in town.
What's more, four of the seventy-six people publicly indicted as war criminals
by the War Crimes Tribunal in The Hague and retained plum positions in the
Prijedor police force. And several of Drlijaca's old colleagues from the
so-called Crisis Staff, which oversaw the district's ethnic cleansing , had
retained high civilian offices in the cleansing's aftermath. For example,
Milan Kovacevic, an anesthetist who reported to have managed the transport of
thousands of his neighbors and colleagues to the concentration camps--from
which many did not emerge alive--had in the meantime become the director of the
Prijedor Hospital, and in that position, according to a Human Rights Watch
report earlier this year, he'd been siphoning off hundreds of thousands of
dollars' worth of international relief assistance.
Here, as elsewhere, the international forces assigned to the town to monitor
compliance with the Dayton agreement have tended to gaze on indifferently. The
tribunal in The Hague has regularly registered pleas that they go after at
least those indictees whose whereabouts were known to everyone (The tribunal,
like most judicial-prosecutorial organs, can't lay claim to any real police
force of its own, and has to rely on others to make the actual arrests.) But
the international forces, under orders from their commanders (who, in turn,
have been taking their lead from the civilian commanders of the various
contributing NATO countries), were entertaining the narrowest possible reading
of their Dayton "mandate": they were technically authorized to make an arrest
if they came upon a suspect during their daily rounds, but they were taking
every possible precaution to avoid doing so.
At the time I arrived in the Republika Srpska, the entire place seemed to have
become criss-crossed with corruption, with all the lines converging on the
wartime capital of Pale, the former ski resort in the mountains above Sarajevo.
Pale had been the site of many of the premier events in the 1984 Winter
Olympics but had since degenerated into a sort of down-market
Berchtesgaden--or, rather, as some of the locally based international
correspondents and peacekeepers had joked during the war, each time they'd had
to undertake the dangerous climb out of besieged Sarajevo, "Well, time to be
heading back to Twin Peaks."
The epithet perfectly captured the spooky, vaguely creepy aura of the place ,
crammed as it was with urbane Sarajevo politicians and businessmen who had
skipped town one fine spring day in 1992, convinced that they would be
returning home in triumph within the week. They'd hardly even bothered to pack
any bags. But one week passed and then another, and then the weeks dragged
into months, and on into years, and they all began going a little stir crazy.
With time, the epithet began to take on additional shadings, evoking the two
leaders who clearly commanded the place--the twin capi di tutti capi at
the top of what had become a double pyramid of extravagant corruption: Radovan
Karadzic, the former psychiatrist, would-be poet, and President of the
Republika Srpska; and Momcilo (Momo) Krajisnik, the one time contractor who had
become the Speaker of the Bosnian Serb Parliament. The two (the former known
for his awesomely big hair, the latter for his awesomely thick eyebrows) had
known each other for years. They had even spent time together in prison back
in the mid-eighties, though not for political crimes. Rather, they had been
convicted in a in a shady business scheme involving the illicit transfer of
funds into a chicken-farming operation.
Karadzic had twice been indicted as a war criminal by the tribunal in The
Hague, for his command responsibilities in the massacre of as many as eight
thousand disarmed Muslim prisoners following the collapse of the supposed safe
haven of Srebenica, in July, 1995, and, before that, for the ethnic cleansing
in general and, in particular, his role in the bombardment of civilians in
Sarejevo, where close to ten thousand died during a three-and-a-half-year
siege. In those days, he had regularly visited his troops overlooking the
city, in order to serenade them--accompanying himself on the single stringed
gusla--with bloodcurdling passages from the Serb epics, evoking a heroic
martyrdoms wending all the way back to the back to the Battle of Kosovo, in
1389.
Karadzic wasn't even supposed to be in Pale anymore, let alone in power there.
Dayton specifically forbade the continued tenure of indicted war criminals.
But NATO personnel tended to ignore the situation. Even after he was finally
forced to resign the Presidency in the lead-up to the parliamentary elections
of September 1996, everybody in the Republika Srpska knew that he retained
complete control over the Serb entity and its still thriving black market and
smuggling operations. After all, his personal enforcer, Interior Minister
Dragan Kijac, had twenty-five to thirty thousand police agents under his
command.
As for Momo Krajisnik, who had not been indicted at The Hague, he was able to
secure the Serb seat on the tripartite cooperative Bosnian State Presidency,
whose effective functioning he immediately started attempting to bollix. But
everyone knew that such machinations absorbed only so much of Krajisnik's time.
For one thing, he had to monitor his family's lumber monopoly, the
spectacularly lucrative foundation of his own illicit empire. Not only was
Krajisnik neglecting to pay taxes on any trees he cut but he didn't seem to
have to pay for the lumber itself: his people were able to chop away pretty
much at will anywhere in the Republika. Who was going to stop them, and who
else was going to try to compete? Meanwhile, the lumber trucks, barrelling
noisily and often perilously through the narrow streets of Pale at all hours of
the day and night, lent the place another of its Twin Peakish aspects.
Everyone knows where Radovan Karadzic lives--in the vast compound on the
outskirts of Pale, ringed by security agents. Everyone knows when he cruises
around town in his chauffeur-driven sedan, unmolested by NATO. Everyone knows
his kids, perennially draped in ill-matched designer clothes and tooling about
in flashy cars. Everyone knows his legion of bodyguards, each of whom appears
to have grown rich in his employ. "Those guys," a longtime resident of Pale
commented to me one morning, dismay spreading across her face as one of them
went racing by in his spanking-new roadster. "They change their cars almost as
often as they change their undershorts." The car careered around a bend and on
out of sight. "More often," she corrected herself.
The Serbs are not only Bosnians afflicted with corruption among their leaders.
Things are almost as bad among the Croatians, and though perhaps not quite as
bad yet in the Muslim sector, they're getting worse there, too. In fact, the
ethnic mafias exist in a state of nearperfect equilibrium.
"Dayton is functioning well at the level of the mafias," another independent
journalist, this one in Bijeljina, told me. "I mean, take the car mafias.
Each of the entities has its own car mafia, and they're in continuous touch
with one another, sometimes even by walkie-talkie. A car gets stolen in
Croatia, it's driven to the Republika Srpska border, where it gets traded for
one stolen on this side. The police on either side claim they can't follow up
on the thieves, because their respective forces don't communicate on an
official level. But some of the same police are often themselves the mafia
guys, or anyway they have been paid off by the mafia to provide phony documents
or else to turn a blind eye. It's a whole elaborate system."
It's a system whose roots go back to the war, perhaps even to before it
started. One afternoon, a United Nations monitor, a veteran of almost five
years in Bosnia, shook his head dispiritedly, saying, "With that war, when you
got down to the ground level, when you got under the skin of it, all the
high-blown ideology and the nationalist rationales just seemed to melt away,
and all you were left with was mad savagery and greed, and it was enough
sometimes to make you sick. And that was true on all sides. Whenever you sat
the leaders down in a room--the heads, as I came to think of them, of the
various heart-of-darkness constituencies--they all understood one another
perfectly well, and they got along famously."
The journalist in Bijeljina, after describing the stolen-car rackets for me,
said he wondered who was using whom. "Did the mafias promote the upsurge of
nationalist feeling from the outset, banking on a war that they'd all
subsequently be able to cash in on?" he asked. "Were the nationalists, for
their part, relying on mafia types to help spread the sort of terror that along
could provoke the kinds of mass exodus that their doctrine of ethnic cleansing
required? Were mafia types masquerading as nationalists, or did they maybe
authentically believe all that stuff, or was it, rather, that the
nationalist--or some of them, anyway--only gradually succumbed to the criminal
temptations all around them? I don't know. I do know that the nationalist
parties maneuvered the country into war, and that the minute it started the
common people on all sides were drafted and sent off to the front, while the
mob operated behind the lines, trading among themselves, stealing and
profiteering and cross-dealing. It was behind the lines that the fortunes
were being made. And it goes on to this day. Those idled factories. Towns
with employment rates of twenty per cent--that's employment, not
unemployment. It's in the leaders' interest: an idle factory's market value
continues to plummet, and now, of course, with the call for market reform and
privatization, the same two or three guys are going to be able to buy up the
whole economy of the Republika Srpska. It just goes on and on."
The question I kept coming back to was why did it go on and on. Why
did the common people of the Republika Srpska, for example, continue to put up
with such shabby and life sapping corruption instead of rising up in
revulsion?
Well, for one thing, the relentless pauperization of the general population
tended to undercut the potential for defiance. What's more, this war waged on
behalf of the Doctrine of Serbian Unity had ended up producing almost
unprecedented disunity among the Serbs. When an entire village was uprooted,
individuals from that village were often scattered among several widely
separated receiving points; the separated refugees were far easier to manage,
far more vulnerable, and, hence, far more deeply in thrall to the whims of the
local officials. Meanwhile, fissures opened up in those newly constituted
townships. After all, what did Herzegovinian peasants have in common with
Bijeljina townsfolk? Time and again, in Bijeljina and Banja Luka and Zvornik
and Vlasenica, I heard townspeople characterizing their new neighbors in terms
dripping with bigoted contempt ("those yokels," "those illiterate-slobs,"
"those shiftless, lazy petty thieves")--indeed, in terms nearly as bigoted as
any they, reserved for their supposed ethnic enemies. In fact, not
infrequently, although in a more circumspect tone of voice, I heard expressions
of nostalgia for the old Muslim neighbors, with whom one at least shared a
certain literacy and sophistication and humor, a frame of reference, a certain
history.
However, if the immediate experience of daily life was one of atomization, the
crushing weight of public pressure was toward an enforced homogenization: the
surrender of any sense of self to the vast collective; the endlessly repeated
need for continued vigilance and the continuing unity of all Serbs behind their
leaders. After all, in each of Bosnia's entities, the principal media were
still in the hands of the same parties and mafias whose hypernationalist
exhortations back in the early nineties had set the stage for war in the first
place.
Over the years, I've repeatedly heard accounts of how age-old and intractable
ethnic hatreds in the Balkans made the recent war inevitable; it's a theory
prized with almost equal fervor by local hypernationalists and foreign
hesitationists, but I don't buy it. I've heard too many times that five years
or two years or six months before the actual outbreak of the war nobody could
have imagined that things were going to come to that--not here in this town,
with these neighbors. The trouble is that, notwithstanding such mild
sentiments, these same people, in overwhelming numbers, had voted from their
respective nationalist parties in the crucial elections of 1990. They'd done
so largely out of propaganda-induced fear--specifically, fear that their
neighbors would be voting for their nationalist parties, and so one had
to support one's own, if only in prudent self-defense.
The same mass psychology that animated the descent toward war five years ago
continues to predominated today: leaders on all sides are able to intone that
if you thing you had cause to fear and hate the other before this war, just
think of all the cause you have now, after everything that's happened since--at
which point the axiomatic life-and-death necessity of falling in behind those
same leaders is meant to become self-evident.
It's a psychological gambit that tends to work. (Among Karadzic's specialties
as a psychiatrist was paranoia. ) Or, anyway, this is how I came to understand
a subsequent remark by the woman who had been complaining so bitterly about how
the Pale bodyguards seemed to change their cars more often than their
undershorts. "Doesn't that annoy people?" I had asked her. "Why don't they
rise up in rebellion?" She smiled, and said, not entirely self-deprecatingly,
"Ah, we Serbs tend to respect successful corruption. You know, the Big
Man--that sort of thing." If our leaders can treat us, whom they purport to
love, in this way, she seemed to imply, just imagine what they'll do, if
necessary, to those we hate in common.
And then there's the tribunal factor. It has been lost on no one that many of
those indicted in The Hague emerged from the war as the leading Mafiosi or
security or political figures in the new order, whereupon they took to feasting
on their own. One might thing that, among the victims of their current
depredations, this would have lent credence to the tribunal's charges against
them, but just the opposite has tended to occur. The indictments get portrayed
as an aspersion against all Serbs--an especially ironic charge, since the
tribunal has repeatedly insisted that it is endeavoring to establish individual
criminal culpability precisely as a way of dispelling imputations of collective
guilt. That message is clearly not getting through. Even more chillingly, the
indictments are repeatedly cast as a potential personal threat to each and
every individual Serb.
So the blockage within seemed total: the leaders entrenched, the populace
entrammelled. Among the international players, everyone seemed to favor
arrests--often vociferously and somewhat self-righteously--only on the
condition that someone else do the actual arresting and, in the end (after
considerable furrowing of brows and poring over mandates), that the leaders of
the various Balkan entities themselves be the ones to do it. And that, of
course, wasn't about to happen. Meanwhile, the economy of the Republika Srpska
lay mired in corruption so thick that neither international investment nor
international assistance seemed likely to come flowing in anytime soon in
anything more than a trickle. History seemed to have got stuck at high
feudalism.
Everything had come to a standstill, and then--history being history--suddenly
everything began to move again. The catalytic agent behind this lurch forward
seemed most improbably: Biljana Plavsic, a thirty-seven-year-old biology
professor, late of the University of Sarajevo, who had been one of the most
fervently hypernationalist bulwarks of the wartime regime in Pale, where she
had been serving as one of two vice-presidents under Karadzic. At the time,
she was dismissed by most observers as an unmitigated wacko. For instance, she
often contended, speaking professionally as a biologist, that Serbs were
genetically superior to Muslims; one day, she even claimed that Bosnia's Serbs
were genetically superior to their metropolitan Serb counterparts, since for
generations they had been required to survive amid their predators. In a
similar vein, she had proposed that Sarajevo should eventually be divided into
two sectors, with most of the city going to the Serbs, since it was well known
that Muslims liked to live on top of one another--it war part of their
nature--whereas Serbs had more normal spatial requirements.
Plavsic was, in sum, from Karadzic's point of view, a truly useful idiot, and,
for that reason, in the summer of 1996, when he was finally forced to
relinquish the Presidency, he had had her installed in his place, as a
delegated puppet. This proved to be a big mistake, for he did not take into
account two salient features of her personality: she was, by all accounts,
personally uncorrupted, and when it came to Serb nationalism she was a true
believer. She really was doing all this for her people, however quaintly naive
that may have seemed.
No sooner had Plavsic been ensconced in the Presidency than, to hear her tell
it, she suddenly became aware of all sorts of shady dealings. During the
winter of 1996-97, Serbia proper erupted in demonstrations against President
Slobodan Milosevic. Along among the Bosnian Serb leaders, Plavsic sent public
messages of support to the Belgrade rallies. She had come to hold Milosevic
responsible as the great archtraitor of modern Serbian history, both for his
betrayal of the Bosnian Serbs at Dayton, where, in a mad scramble to reinvent
himself as the indispensable Man of Peace, he heedlessly sacrificed their
claims to, among other things, Sarajevo. (It's worth noting here that, just as
the initial upsurge of Bosnian Serb nationalism before the war had been but a
side manifestation of Milosevic's own grotesquely opportunistic lunge for power
back in Belgrade, so the Twin Peaks of Bosnian Serb corruption during and after
the war were but foothills to the veritable Himalaya of such venalities that
constitute the essence of Milosevic's regime.)
In the months that followed, Plavsic made a few tentative attempts at curbing
the excesses of he security police tied to Karadzic's enforcer, Interior
Minister Kijac, but then pulled back in the fact of his manifestly superior
power. After that, she seemed to disappear from the scene; indeed, she was
seen less and less in Pale, having repaired to Banja Luka, the Republika
Srpska's only real city.
In early June, the new American Secretary of State, Madeleine Albright, who had
been a longtime proponent of more robust rules of engagement for international
forces in Bosnia, and had probably grown tired of Washington's endless
bureaucratic seesawing on the subject, set off on a whirlwind tour of the
former Yugoslavia--in part, apparently, to see if she might be able to stir
things up on the ground. As one element of that trip, she met with President
Plavsic, in her Banja Luka office, for almost an hour and a half. Albright
appears to have warned Plavsic that the Republika Srpska existed, to the extent
that it existed at all, only by virtue of the umbrella provided by the Dayton
agreement, and that American and NATO patience was fast running out.
Four weeks later, on July 2nd, Plavsic, taking full advantage of the
prerogatives of her office, delivered a televised address to the nation, which
the nation absorbed, drop-jawed in amazement. At last, somebody was saying
what everyone had been thinking but hardly anyone else had dared speak of in
anything more than a whisper behind closed doors. And over Pale television, no
less! Having described the Republika Srpska as "a state in which the budget
actually does not exist, where police are involved in smuggling and stealing
from their own state, and where a majority of the population is living in
abject poverty," Plavsic went on to note that, while bribes and illicit profits
coursed regularly into the pockets of a few individuals, the state, bereft of
revenue, was unable to pay its teachers or its doctors, or even to bankroll the
proper upkeep of its Army. Then, rehearsing the history of her Interior
Minister's blatant insubordinations, she noted how he might well be "receiving
instructions from somebody else, who, according to the constitution, has been
barred from such activities since the September elections"--a direct jab as
Karadzic. In any case, she continues, "I am insisting on Minister Kijac's
resignation."
After alluding to the warnings she had clearly received from Secretary
Albright, she reminded her listeners that "seventeen thousand young people gave
their lives for this state," further insisting that its current course could
lead only to catastrophe. "Dear people of the Republika Srpska," she
concluded, "all that is being asked is respect for the law. All that is being
asked is that responsible people behave responsibly toward the state. An end
has to be put to the gray economy, to crime, and to the habits of the past. We
do not have much time."
On that last point, at least, Karadzic and Krajisnik and Kijac seemed to be in
full agreement. Kijac announced that he would ignore his dismissal, while
Karadzic and Krajisnik rushed to mobilize their allies in parliament for a
special session, aimed at securing the President's removal. Plavsic was not
without options of her own, however, at least on paper. Taking advantage of
the remarkable constitutional prerogatives assigned to the Presidency (an
office that had been custom-designed to meet the commodious specifications of
Karadzic himself), she preemptively suspended parliament and called for new
elections in September. "Oh, yeah?" the Twin Peaks seemed to reply. "You and
whose police force?" They convened the parliament anyway--or as much of its as
they could muster--and began moving toward her ouster.
Plavsic started addressing steadily growing rallies, but Karadzic and his
forces retained control of the police and of state television, and they
blanketed the airwaves with increasingly vitriolic attacks on the President,
regularly charging her with having sold out to Republika to the Americans.
Meanwhile, if Albright had been intending to stir things up in the Balkans so
as to shake them up back in Washington, she certainly seemed to have succeeded.
As the NATO leaders gathered for a summit in Madrid, on July 8th and 9th, there
were growing indications that, in the light of the perilously unfolding power
struggle in the Republika Srpska, the famously constricted "mandate" might be
due for expansion.
And indeed, just a few days later, on July 10th, NATO forces struck. Acting on
a set of secret indictments, British special-forces teams swooped down on
Prijedor, arresting the hospital director, Milan Kovacevic, in his office
without a struggle, and engaging Mr. Ten Per Cent--Simo Drljaca, the notorious
police chief who had helped oversee the cleansing of Prijedor--in a firefight,
in which he ended up dead.
The action was clear indication of a decided, if only momentary, change in NATO
policy--but it was also somewhat problematic. For one thing, there was the
failure to capture Drljaca alive. Granted, he had fired first, and the
military commanders had all along complained that their people were never
trained for this sort of police role. Still, he would have been an immensely
important catch for the tribunal, especially when coupled with Kovacevic, who
in several interviews over the last eighteen months has been showing signs of
being as pickled in guilt as he is in alcohol.
At the end of July, Kovacevic was brought before the tribunal and pleaded not
guilty. But if somehow, down the line, he can be caused to "turn," he could
provide immensely detailed information on the horrific Prijedor cleansing.
Command responsibilities for that campaign, however, led through Drljaca and
from him on up to Belgrade and, possibly, to Milosevic himself. With Drljaca's
death, yet another of the evidentiary trails that could have led toward
Milosevic has been sundered.
But even more problematic than the outcome of these arrests was the choice of
targets. These weren't small fry, by any means. (Drljaca, in particular,
would have been included in almost anybody's Top Five list.) Rather, the issue
was whether, especially given the current political crisis, with Karadzic's
popularity at an all-time low amid the charges of corruption, it might not have
made more sense to go after him first.
At any rate, the raid proved a disastrous setback--in the short term, at
least--for President Plavsic. Pale television went on the offensive, playing
film clips of the Albright-Plavsic meeting virtually non-stop while intimating
that the President was guilty of treason. The attack was portrayed once again
as an attack on all Serbs, and they were once again enjoined to hunker down,
themselves against the world--a struggle that Plavsic was clearly no longer in
a position to lead.
Posters went up all over the Republika showing photographs of a defiant
Karadzic underscored by stark warnings--in English--to NATO forces: "Don't
Touch Him" because "He Means Peace." A campaign of pinprick terrorism swept
the region, ranging from midnight bombings of cars parked outside the homes of
international observers to swipes at patrolling soldiers (by, variously,
scythes and speeding Mercedeses). This was a game at which the Serbs were
past-masters--the sort of thing that used to thoroughly spook Western
leaders.
And yet it didn't seem to be working this time. The new Labour Foreign
Secretary in Britain, Robin Cook, didn't seem the least bit fazed. The new
American military commander on the scene, General Wesley Clark, seemed to be
taking a decidedly broader view of his mandate than his predecessor, General
George Joulwan, and so did the new civilian High Representative, Spain's Carlos
Westendorp: he began making comments to the effect that not only would the
war criminals have to be arrested in short order but corruption's was going to
be flushed out--perhaps by freezing foreign bank accounts. Even the old
players were making new noises: NATO's secretary-general, Javier Solana, of
Spain (a friend and former colleague of Westendorp's), was suddenly declaring
that he wouldn't consider NATO's Bosnian mission complete until all the
indicted war criminals had been delivered to The Hague. All these foreigners
were converging on the region, and so was Richard Holbrooke, the architect of
the Dayton agreement, whom President Clinton hauled out of retirement for one
last arm-twisting tour in the first week of August, including yet another, and
perhaps final showdown with his old Dayton partner, the arch-villain Milosevic
himself.
Whether the huffing and puffing would amount to anything remained to be seen.
But there did seem to be a new sense of urgency--a sense that the next few
weeks could decide the fate of the Dayton dream of a federated Bosnia, at
peace, in which refugees might once again be able to return to their homes and
ordinary people be allowed, finally, to take up the rebuilding of their
communities.
Nevertheless, even with all this new activism, it may be just too late to
envision any sort of true ethnic reintegration for Bosnia. That's the
reluctant conclusion toward which the Belgrade-based political analyst Aleksa
Djilas--son of the great dissident Milovan Djilas, and himself an inveterate
nonnationalist--has recently found himself tending. "I mean," he suggested
hesitantly, "it' s a little like a situation where a beautiful woman is walking
down the street and a madman dashes up to her and slashes her face with a
razor, exultantly screaming, 'Ha ha, ha ha, you'll never be beautiful again!'
Sometime later, the woman goes to a plastic surgeon, and the doctor examines
her carefully, tenderly, before sighing, "Alas, alas, you'll never be beautiful
again.' It's the same sentence but with two radically different
connotations--the difference between advocacy and diagnosis." He was quiet for
a few moments, then added, "And, alas, alas, maybe Bosnia never will be
beautiful again."
Maybe. And maybe even worse. For if the international forces now hesitate
again (and history affords small cause for confidence in this regard), and if
Plavsic loses out--or maybe even if she wins (because, for all her daring, she
remains an unreconstructed hypernationalist)--the Bosnian Serbs may continue
obdurately refusing to cooperate in any meaningful way in the peaceful
reintegration of the country, and at that point NATO may really give up in
exasperation. If the Americans do pull out by July, 1998, as they are
currently scheduled to do, everyone else will pull out as well.
Then, in all likelihood, the war will resume, and it could be a very short war.
The Federation Army has been steadily building itself up, and the Serbs can no
longer rely on the monopoly of heavy weaponry, upon which they based their
spectacular early success in the last war. In fact, the Republika Srpska Army
is completely demoralized and gutted of effective leadership. The Muslims will
be fighting to return to the idealized fantasies of their former homes, while
the Serbs will only be defending the wretched wasteland that their leaders have
made of their current ones. Their leaders have made of their current ones.
Their leaders, meanwhile, will very likely have skipped town, their wealth
securely socked away in Cypriot bank accounts, their Belgrade villas handsomely
outfitted--just as the Serb leaders did in the Croatian Krajina and in Western
Herzegovina before the outbreak of the final Bosnian-Croat offensive in 1995.
The war, then will be short and brutal, with perhaps a million Bosnian Serbs
being forced from the lands their ancestors inhabited for centuries, and
regulated to a life of abject desolation as refugees among the Serbs of
Belgrade, who will have at last achieved the dark realization of the dream that
Milosevic originally sold them on ten years ago: all Serbs in one state,
indeed. The metropolitan Serbs will despise these new refugees (just as they
despise the current crop) as the persistent mirror of their own onetime folly,
and they will make the refugees know it. And that will be that. Except that,
of course, it won't be. Those desolate shantytowns will doubtless incubate the
next batch of history's aggrieved Serbs, avid for revenge and just itching for
the next Fascist crusade to come along.
Or, then again, maybe not. There's a field alongside the road between Tuzla
and Breko, near the place where the highway crosses over from the Muslim-Croat
Federation into the Republika Srpska. It was once the site of pitched battles,
salted with trenches and mines, and, in fact, it marks the place where the war
came to an end. Once the Americans arrived, they cleared the minefields and
established a frontier checkpoint, and, little by little, merchants from either
side of the divide started coming to trade. Nowadays, by eight or so in the
morning the place is swarming, with tens of thousands of merchants and
customers trading everything from cassette tapes and batteries and detergents
and vegetables to stoves and cars and cattle--everything, they like to say,
from pins to locomotives.
There are claptrap bars and outdoor cafes, and at one of those cafes, one
afternoon, I happened upon a group of about eight merchants, relaxing after a
busy day, joshing and ribbing and laughing up a storm. Two of the guys were
Serbs, another was a Croat; there were two Muslims, a Montenegrin, and even a
Hungarian, from the Vojvodina. I asked if any of them had fought in the war.
"Oh, sure, " one of the Serbs said, laughing. "In fact, I was stationed right
up there." He turned, indicating the hills behind him. "And you were firing
at me over there," on of the Muslims chimed in, pointing in the other direction
and laughing just as hard. "A pathetic shot!" A waitress brought a round of
drinks, and everybody toasted everything. I asked whither it felt strange for
them to be gathered together like this after so much killing. The other Serb
fixed me with his eyes. "Look, " he said, "The thing you have to understand
is that for eight hundred years around these parts, going all the way back to
the Middle Ages..." Oh, no. I felt myself deflating. Here is all comes
again: the Battle of Kosovo, the massacres during the Second World War, the
endless, endlessness of it all. "For eight hundred years, " he repeated,
"people around here have lived with each other in peace. Catholics,
Muslims, Orthodox ,Jews. In peace. No one anywhere else has been able to pull
such a thing off. Sure, every once in a while some crooked politicians come
along and muck everything up, but eventually they leave, and we're all still
here. And people here know how to get along."
| |