Since detailed inmate survey data for recent years are only available for 1986
and 1991, we need to rely on these years to suggest trends which may influence
current dynamics. As can be seen, the absolute increase for violent offenders
was virtually identical for blacks and whites (31,000 and 33,000 respectively),
but for drug offenses, the black increase outpaced that for whites by 66,000 to
15,000, a 465.5% just five years. Absent data regarding the racial breakdown
of persons involved in drug crimes, these trends may reflect the impact of
"drug war" policies in inner cities and the fact that when discretion is more
prevalent in the criminal justice system, minorities may suffer greater
consequences.
Finally, a look at the numbers of persons sentenced to prison from 1988 to 1992
(the most recent year for which data are available) in Table 7 again shows
substantial increases in prison sentences for both violent offenders and drug
offenders. Here, too, while the proportional increase for violent offenses is
relatively similar for blacks and whites, the increase for black drug offenders
is dramatically higher, 94.1% compared to 35.1%. The pattern for the number of
commitments for violent offenses is consistent with data that show that while
African Americans are disproportionately arrested for violent crimes, these
proportions have not changed substantially for twenty years.
In Minnesota, the state with the highest ratio of racial disparity, sentencing
trends over the past decade suggest that blacks have been arrested and received
prison terms for violent offenses at increasingly higher rates than whites, but
dramatically more so for drug offenses. For violent offenses, the increase in
felony sentences for blacks outpaced that for whites by 287% to 40% for murder,
316% to 68% for assault, and 121% to a decline of 5% for robbery between 1984
and 1994. For drug offenses, though, the black rate increased by 1096%
compared to 71% for whites.
|