| | |
|
Henry E. Adams, Lester W. Wright' Jr., and Bethany A. Lohr conducted this research at the Psychology Department of the University of Georgia, where Dr. Adams is now professor emeritus.
| |
Hostility and discrimination against homosexual individuals are
well-established facts. On occasion, these negative attitudes lead to hostile
verbal and physical acts against gay individuals with little apparent
motivation except a strong dislike. In fact, more than 90% of gay men and
lesbians report being targets of verbal abuse or threats, and more than
one-third report being survivors of violence related to their homosexuality.
Although negative attitudes and behaviors toward gay individuals have been
assumed to be associated with rigid moralistic beliefs, sexual ignorance, and
fear of homosexuality, the etiology of these attitudes and behaviors remains a
puzzle. Weinberg ( 1972 ) labeled these attitudes and behaviors homophobia,
which he defined as the dread of being in close quarters with homosexual
men and women as well as irrational fear, hatred, and intolerance by
heterosexual individuals of homosexual men and women. . . .
Although the causes of homophobia are unclear, several psychoanalytic
explanations have emerged from the idea of homophobia as an anxiety-based
phenomenon. One psychoanalytic explanation is that anxiety about the
possibility of being or becoming a homosexual may be a major factor in
homophobia. For example, de Kuyper (1993) has asserted that homophobia is the
result of the remnants of homosexuality in the heterosexual resolution of the
Oedipal conflict. Whereas these notions are vague, psychoanalytic theories
usually postulate that homophobia is a result of repressed homosexual urges or
a form of latent homosexuality. Latent homosexuality can be defined as
homosexual arousal which the individual is either unaware of or dent.
Psychoanalysts use the concept of repressed or latent homosexuality to explain
the emotional malaise and irrational attitudes displayed by some individuals
who feel guilty about their erotic interests and struggle to deny and repress
homosexual impulses. In fact, West stated, 'when placed in a situation that
threatens to excite their own unwanted homosexual thoughts, they overreact with
panic or anger." Slaby ( 1994 ) contended that anxiety about homosexuality
typically does not occur in individuals who are same-sex oriented, but it
usually involves individuals who are ostensibly heterosexual and have
difficulty integrating their homosexual feelings or activity. The relationship
between homophobia and latent homosexuality has not been empirically
investigated and is one of the purposes of the present study.
Specifically, the present study was designed to investigate whether homophobic
men show more sexual arousal to homosexual cues than nonhomophobic men as
suggested by psychoanalytic theory. . . .
The results of this study indicate that individuals who score in the
homophobic range and admit negative affect toward homosexuality demonstrate significant sexual
arousal to male homosexual erotic stimuli. These individuals were selected
on the basis of their report of having only heterosexual arousal and
experiences. Furthermore, their ratings of erection and arousal to homosexual
stimuli were low and not significantly different from nonhomophobic men who
demonstrated no significant increase in penile response to homosexual stimuli.
These data are consistent with response discordance where verbal judgments are
not consistent with physiological reactivity, as in the case of homophobic
individuals viewing homosexual stimuli. Lang (1994 ) has noted that the most
dramatic response discordance occurs with reports of feeling and physiologic
responses. Another possible explanation is found in various psychoanalytic
theories, which have generally explained homophobia as a threat to an
individual's own homosexual impulses causing repression, denial, or reaction
formation (or all three; West, 1977 ). Generally, these varied explanations
conceive of homophobia as one type of latent homosexuality where persons either
are unaware of or deny their homosexual urges. These data are consistent with
these notions.
Another explanation of these data is found in Barlow, Sakheim, and Beck's (
1983) theory of the role of anxiety and attention in sexual responding. It is
possible that viewing homosexual stimuli causes negative emotions such as
anxiety in homophobic men but not in nonhomophobic men. Because anxiety has
been shown to enhance arousal and erection, this theory would predict increases
in erection in homophobic men. Furthermore, it would indicate that a response
to homosexual stimuli is a function of the threat condition rather than sexual
arousal per se. Whereas difficulties of objectively evaluating psychoanalytic
hypotheses are well-documented, these approaches would predict that sexual
arousal is an intrinsic response to homosexual stimuli, whereas Barlow's (1986
) theory would predict that sexual arousal to homosexual stimuli by homophobic
individuals is a function of anxiety. These competing potions can and should
be evaluated by future research.
The hypothesis that homophobic men are merely aggressive is not supported by
the present data. There were no differences in aggression scores
between groups as measured by the Aggression Questionnaire. . . .
| |
Excerpted with permission from Henrey E. Adams, Lester W. Wright Jr., and Bethany A Lohr, Is Homophobia Associated With Homosexual Arousal? in the Journal of Abnormal Psychology, Vol. 105., No. 3 (1996), pp. 440-445. Footnotes and tables omitted. | |
|